Skip to content

Investing

Roth Conversion or Rollover IRA: Which Should a Business Owner Do?

· Kyle Simmons

Line illustration of a conference table with two file folders, one plum folder sliding toward an open binder.

Should you do a Roth conversion or rollover IRA move with that old 401(k)? Short answer: they're different tools, and most owners end up using both.

Here's how I think about each one, and how I explain it to owners.

  • A rollover moves retirement money to a new account, while a Roth conversion moves pre-tax money into a Roth account and usually creates taxable income.
  • A direct rollover is where the money goes straight from one institution to the other.
  • If you use a Backdoor Roth IRA, rolling an old pre-tax 401(k) into an IRA can make your backdoor Roth strategy taxable.
  • Roth conversions usually make the most sense in lower-income years, done in pieces and paid for with cash from outside the account.

Roth Conversion or Rollover IRA: What's the Difference?

A rollover changes where your money lives. A Roth conversion changes how it's taxed.

A rollover moves money from an old workplace plan, like a 401(k), into an IRA or your current workplace plan. Done correctly, pre-tax money stays pre-tax and no tax is due.

A Roth conversion moves pre-tax money into a Roth IRA. You generally pay income tax on the amount converted that year. In exchange, Roth investments grow tax free and withdrawals come out tax-free, and Roth IRAs don't require RMDs (required minimum distributions) for the original owner.

Owners usually want three things: smaller required withdrawals later, more control over when they pay tax, and fewer stray accounts. Both tools help, but they solve different problems.

How Should I Move an Old 401(k) Without Paying Tax?

We normally suggest using a direct rollover. The old plan sends the money straight to the new account, and you never touch it.

  1. Open the receiving account first: an IRA, or your current workplace plan if it accepts roll-ins.
  2. Ask the old plan for a direct rollover, payable to the new custodian for your benefit.
  3. Confirm the money landed and was coded as a rollover.

The alternative is an indirect rollover. The plan cuts you a check, and you have 60 days from receipt to deposit it (source). Miss it, and the IRS will happily treat the whole thing as a withdrawal. We really don't like this method.

Plans also typically withhold part of that check for taxes. To roll over the full amount, you'd have to cover the missing piece from your own pocket. Again, this is why I dislike this method so much.

The Backdoor Roth Catch

If your income is too high to contribute to a Roth IRA directly (2026 phase-out for married filing jointly: $242,000 to $252,000, source), you may be using a Backdoor Roth IRA strategy. That's where an old 401(k) rollover to an IRA can backfire.

The pro-rata rule means that when you convert, the IRS looks at all your traditional IRA balances together. Roll pre-tax money into an IRA, and most of your Backdoor conversion becomes taxable. Ouch.

Illustrative only: You roll a $90,000 pre-tax 401(k) into an IRA, then make a nondeductible contribution of $7,500 (2026 limit: $7,500 per person, source). Your total IRA balance is $97,500, and only about 8% of it is after-tax. Convert $7,500, and roughly $6,900 of it is taxable.

My two cents: if you do Backdoor Roth contributions, roll old 401(k) money into your current workplace plan instead, if the plan allows it. If you don't, an IRA is usually the simpler home.

When Does a Roth Conversion Make Sense for an Owner?

A Roth conversion usually makes sense in a year when your income is lower than normal and you can pay the tax from cash outside the account.

Type of yearConversion fit
Big profit year for the practice or firmUsually poor. Conversion income stacks on top.
Down year from expansion, associate hiring or heavy equipment purchasesOften worth a look.
Years after a sale, before other retirement income startsOften the best window.
You'd pay the tax out of the IRA itselfUsually poor. Less money ends up in the Roth.

We prefer several partial conversions over one big one. Spreading conversions across years keeps more of the income in lower tax brackets.

We run a projection before each conversion, usually late in the year when income is clearer. That's a core part of our year-round tax planning for business owners.

If a sale is on the horizon, those post-sale years matter. Start by checking whether you could retire without the sale.

What Can Go Wrong With Conversions and Rollovers?

  • Conversions can't be undone. If the year turns out bigger than expected, you're stuck with the tax.
  • Extra income from a conversion can shrink deductions that phase out at higher incomes, or raise Medicare premiums later. Confirm current thresholds with your advisor
  • Old 401(k)s that hold after-tax money need careful handling. Ask before moving them to make sure the allocation is handled properly.

The Takeaway

Rollover first, conversion second, and both with a plan. Use a direct rollover, watch where the money lands if you do Backdoor Roth contributions, and convert in pieces during lower-income years.

As always, the details matter. Coordinate with your CPA or advisor before acting.

If you'd like a second set of eyes on your accounts, see how our process and fees work and book an intro call.

Disclosure

The content and information presented herein are for educational purposes only and should not be construed as a solicitation or offer to buy or sell any investment services. Nothing contained in this material should be considered an offer to provide any product or service in any jurisdiction that would be unlawful under the securities laws of that jurisdiction. The information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable; however, the Firm does not guarantee accuracy or completeness of the information. Such information is subject to change at any time without notice. Before taking any action, you should consult with a qualified tax, legal, or financial professional.

This article is for informational purposes only and is not individualised investment, tax, or legal advice. See our disclaimer.

Ready to get started?

Questions about your own situation?

No preparation needed. We'll confirm fit and outline next steps.

Book an intro call

Not ready to talk? Subscribe to Insights instead.